Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Iran Open to U.S. Talks but Demands Accountability and Compensation
    • Udaipur Files Ban Sparks Heartfelt Clash Over Truth and Harmony
    • Adani’s Dharavi Dream Devastates Mumbai’s Poor as Elites Seize Control
    • India’s Censorship Scandal Explodes: Reuters Blocked, Musk’s X Defies Modi’s Government
    • China Slams Trump’s Tariff Threat to BRICS Nations: “We Oppose Coercion Through Tariffs”
    • Senate’s “Most Dangerous” Tax Bill Sparks Outrage as Democrats Unite Against Billionaire Bailout
    • Paramount’s $16 Million Settlement with Trump Over ‘60 Minutes’ Lawsuit
    • Cricmax Connect: Powering the Organic Growth of Cricket in America
    • About
    • Careers
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Digpu NewsDigpu News
    Saturday, July 12
    • Home
    • World
    • India
    • Business
    • Tech
    • Sports
    • More
      • Achievers
      • Auto Tech
      • Diplomatic Diary
      • Dil Paziir
      • Education
      • Entertainment
      • Finance
      • Health
      • Opinion
      • Politics
      • Press release
      • Startup
      • Science & Nature
      • Travel
    Digpu NewsDigpu News
    Home » India News » Leena Manimekalai’s Kaali stirs ‘right to free speech’ debate

    Leena Manimekalai’s Kaali stirs ‘right to free speech’ debate

    By News DeskJuly 5, 2022Updated:July 5, 2022 India News No Comments5 Mins Read
    Leena Manimekalai’s Kaali stirs ‘right to free speech’ debate?
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Kaali was first screened during Rhythms of Canada, a week-long festival celebrating multiculturalism, at the Aga Khan Museum in Toronto

    Leena Manimekalai, an independent filmmaker, attracted criticism online days after tweeting the cover image for her most recent documentary Kaali.

    The image shared last Saturday depicts a lady wearing a Goddess Kaali costume smoking a cigarette while carrying a pride flag, which stands for the LGBT community.

    Kaali was originally shown at the Aga Khan Museum in Toronto last weekend during Rhythms of Canada, a week-long celebration honouring multiculturalism.

    The film’s plot, according to the filmmaker, centres on the events that happen one evening when Kaali arrives and wanders the streets of Toronto.

    Online backlash over the Kaali poster led to calls for her imprisonment and accusations that she had offended religious feelings. The hashtag “#ArrestLeenaManimekalai” quickly became a trending hashtag on Twitter.

    ‘If speaking without fear costs my life, I will give it’

    The Canadian-born Manimekalai advised her followers on Twitter to use the hashtag “#LoveYouLeenaManimekalai” rather than “#ArrestLeenaManimekalai” on Monday in response to the outcry on social media.

    “No harm can come to me. Until it is, I want to be with a voice that speaks without hesitation. I will lose my life if that is the price,” she said in a tweet made in Tamil.

    Manimekalai, who is from the village of Maharajapuram in Virudhunagar, Tamil Nadu, has worked on critically praised films including Madathi and Sengadal: The Dead Sea.

    Police complaint filed over the controversial poster

    In the meantime, a Delhi-based lawyer on Monday reported Manimekalai to the police over her contentious documentary poster.

    According to the complainant lawyer, Mr Vineet Jindal, the Director has offended his religious emotions by presenting Goddess Kaali as smoking. He described it as exceedingly offensive and not acceptable in any way.

    Mr Jindal demanded that a formal complaint be filed against the independent filmmaker immediately, claiming that the depiction of the Hindu Goddess in such a despicable way is hurtful to the beliefs and feelings of the Hindu community.

    Films and controversies co-occur regularly

    Several movies and television shows have already faced criticism for purportedly hurting religious emotions.

    For instance, Twitterati criticised Anurag Basu’s “Ludo” for allegedly pushing ‘Hinduphobic’ ideas in the film. The online series “Taandav,” starring Saif Ali Khan, sparked controversy in 2021 for reportedly inciting religious conflict by disparaging Hindu deities.

    Right to free speech in the present times

    The definitions of free speech and hate speech are hotly contested, despite the fact that the Indian Constitution expressly guarantees the right to free speech (which also includes creative expression).

    Many people found the image to be unsettling, particularly in light of the nation’s unstable political environment and the ongoing communal conflicts.

    In the last couple of months alone, an objectionable statement by BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma during a TV debate led to nationwide protests and clashes between Hindus and Muslims, followed by massive blowback by nations. Unfortunately, this resulted in the gruesome and terrifying murder of Kanhaiya Lal in Rajasthan’s Udaipur.

    The whole idea of “India” is murdered! #udaipur

    — Leena Manimekalai (@LeenaManimekali) June 28, 2022

    Directors and filmmakers must use discretion when depicting religious figures, regardless of faith, in a way that can offend a community given the tumultuous character of the current period, during which there have been significant protests in all Indian cities.

    India’s CBFC is comparatively stricter

    The Cinematograph Act of 1952 established a strict process for approving films for public consumption – commercial films shown in movie theatres and other public viewings – even if the producers fail to show proper regard for the religious views of people. Additionally, it is accountable for the existence of the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC).

    In comparison to certification bodies from its time, the CBFC operates with far greater rigour. In addition to categorising movies, it also recommends edits and deletions to the media’s content in accordance with regulations set forth by the government.

    In contrast, the British Board of Film Classification’s officers only examine and categorise movies according to the recommended age bracket or suggest changing the age group that the movie’s creator had originally designated. Similar to this, parents in the United States select whether films are suitable for children to watch through the Classification and Rating Administration (CARA).

    India needs to uphold civil liberties

    However, according to a number of international rankings, the country’s civil freedoms are indeed deteriorating. India had a Civil Liberties Rating of 33/60 in the Freedom in the World report published by Freedom House in 2021. The country was placed 142nd out of 180 nations that year in the World Press Freedom Index, down from its 2017 level of 133rd.

    Given the dwindling state of civil liberties in the country, a lot of work needs to be done not only to improve the country’s ranking in such international rankings but also to change the perception of the people of the Western countries towards the nation. Obviously, the people living in India should enjoy civil liberties including religious freedom at par with developed countries like the United States.

    Freedom Of Speech Goddess Kaali Leena Manimekalai
    News Desk

      Read the latest updates from all over the world.

      Keep Reading

      Udaipur Files Ban Sparks Heartfelt Clash Over Truth and Harmony

      Adani’s Dharavi Dream Devastates Mumbai’s Poor as Elites Seize Control

      India’s Censorship Scandal Explodes: Reuters Blocked, Musk’s X Defies Modi’s Government

      Political Constraints and Losses in Operation Sindoor – Why the Silence?

      Leaked Tape Sparks Controversy Over Manipur Chief Minister’s Role

      Hindenburg Research Exposes SEBI Chairperson’s Alleged Ties to Adani Group’s Offshore Financial Network

      Add A Comment
      Leave A Reply

      You must be logged in to post a comment.

      Latest

      Iran Open to U.S. Talks but Demands Accountability and Compensation

      July 11, 2025

      Udaipur Files Ban Sparks Heartfelt Clash Over Truth and Harmony

      July 11, 2025

      Adani’s Dharavi Dream Devastates Mumbai’s Poor as Elites Seize Control

      July 9, 2025

      India’s Censorship Scandal Explodes: Reuters Blocked, Musk’s X Defies Modi’s Government

      July 9, 2025

      Iran Open to U.S. Talks but Demands Accountability and Compensation

      July 11, 2025

      Udaipur Files Ban Sparks Heartfelt Clash Over Truth and Harmony

      July 11, 2025

      Adani’s Dharavi Dream Devastates Mumbai’s Poor as Elites Seize Control

      July 9, 2025

      India’s Censorship Scandal Explodes: Reuters Blocked, Musk’s X Defies Modi’s Government

      July 9, 2025
      About
      About

      Digpu News – Free Voice With A Critical Edge: At Digpu.com, we embody the spirit of ‘Free Voice With A Critical Edge.‘ Our mission is to reinvent the very idea of news. Launched in 2018, our independent daily English online news channel has set the standard for true journalism—emphasizing accuracy, reliability, relevance, and impartiality.

      Follow Us!
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Pinterest
      • Instagram
      • YouTube
      Highlights
      Iran Open to U.S. Talks but Demands Accountability and Compensation

      Udaipur Files Ban Sparks Heartfelt Clash Over Truth and Harmony

      Adani’s Dharavi Dream Devastates Mumbai’s Poor as Elites Seize Control

      India’s Censorship Scandal Explodes: Reuters Blocked, Musk’s X Defies Modi’s Government

      Subscribe to Digpu
      © 2025 Digpu News Network. All rights reserved.
      • Terms of Use
      • Site Map
      • Privacy Policy
      • Disclaimer

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.